Disclosure: This content may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.
Everything you think about hiking—from gear choices to trail etiquette—deserves a second look.
When was the last time you questioned why you pack your hiking backpack the way you do? Or considered why you feel compelled to reach every summit? Or wondered why you apologize to anyone when taking a photo?
Hiking, like any passion, accumulates layers of unexamined “shoulds” and “musts” that we inherit from guides, social media, fellow hikers, and gear manufacturers. Every hiker has their die-hard beliefs about the right way to hit the trails, from gear choices to destination picks to what even counts as a “real” hike. These assumptions silently shape our experiences, sometimes enriching them, but often limiting them in ways we don’t notice.
What Serves Us Best?
This isn’t about rejecting traditional practices wholesale. It’s about understanding why we do what we do, and consciously choosing what serves us best on the trail today, and what might serve us even better tomorrow.
After more miles than I been able to track, I’ve developed some personal opinions that might ruffle a few feathers in the hills. What follows are perspectives that challenge conventional hiking wisdom. They’re not meant to replace anyone’s current approach, but rather to expand our view of what’s possible on the trail.
After all, if the wilderness teaches us to be adaptable, shouldn’t our attitudes about hiking be just as flexible? Sometimes, growth and depth come not from learning new stuff, but from unlearning old stuff…
The Eleven Opinions
1. Summiting Is Overrated
The “summit or bust” mindset has hijacked hiking culture, often at the expense of the journey itself. Some of my most treasured moments happened well below any summit: stumbling upon a hidden waterfall, a deer staring intently at me, an epic ledge view, my one experience seeing a bear. While standing on a summit makes for an undeniable rush, fixating on summits means missing countless memorable and even magical moments along the way.
2. Foggy Hikes Are Superior to Clear Days
Bold statement? Maybe. But fog transforms familiar trails into eerie, beautiful landscapes. While bluebird days offer sweeping views, misty conditions create an intimate, otherworldly experience. There’s something fantastic about watching fog part to reveal glimpses of valleys below or distant peaks. Plus, you’ll enjoy cooler temperatures and smaller crowds—perfect conditions for a memorable hike.
3. Hiking Lists Limit Adventure
“Must-do” hiking lists make great starting points for beginners, but they shouldn’t become hiking handcuffs. The compulsion to complete lists like the 4000-footers or the Pacific Crest Trail often leads people to bypass equally stunning but lesser-known paths. Many of the finest Catskills and Adirondack hikes are not high peak hikes. These lists create arbitrary hierarchies that suggest some hikes “count” more than others. Use them as inspiration, not obligation.
4. Leave No Trace Needs Nuance & Chill
Note: This opinion often sparks debate, and for good reason. While Leave No Trace (LNT) principles provide crucial guidelines, some interpretations have become needlessly rigid. Nature shows remarkable resilience—a bootprint or scattered leaves won’t devastate an ecosystem. Instead of promoting complete isolation from nature, let’s focus on teaching responsible interaction with it.
5. The Great Trekking Pole Debate
Trekking poles have their place, particularly on steep descents or stream crossings. However, they often disrupt natural movement patterns on moderate terrain. The automatic assumption that every hiker needs poles deserves scrutiny. Sometimes, they become a crutch that prevents developing natural balance and rhythm on the trail. Personally, I carry mine all the time — but only deploy them as needed on steep descents to help save my knees and help with balance.
Get access to hyper-detailed trail guides, insider tips, and expert advice. Join a vibrant community of like-minded hikers, receive exclusive content, and embark on unforgettable outdoor adventures. Whether you’re a seasoned outdoor enthusiast or just starting out on your hiking journey, this website provides invaluable resources to help you explore the best trails in the Catskills, Adirondacks, Hudson Highlands, Berkshires, and beyond. Get access now to all content on this website instantly and enjoy unique supporter benefits.
6. The Footwear Fallacy
Let’s end the hiking boots versus trail runners debate once and for all. What matters isn’t the category—it’s how well your footwear fits and supports your unique needs as a hiker. I’ve seen hikers tackle technical trails expertly in well-fitted trail runners while others struggle in premium boots that don’t suit their feet or style. The best footwear? Whatever you can forget you’re wearing.
7. The 10 Essentials Need an Update
The 10 Essentials concept remains valid, but blindly carrying every item on every hike makes little sense. Context matters. A summer afternoon trek on a popular trail near civilization demands different preparation than a remote backcountry expedition. Learn to assess your needs based on conditions, location, and experience.
8. The Ultralight Obsession
While the ultralight movement has revolutionized hiking gear, it’s created unnecessary pressure to minimize weight at all costs. Traditional gear often provides better durability and value for casual hikers. Not everyone needs a sub-two-pound tent or frameless backpack. Sometimes, a few extra ounces mean significantly more comfort and reliability.
9. Social Media’s Impact on Hiking Culture
The quest for “Instagrammable“ moments has fundamentally altered hiking’s essence. Too often, hikers rush past beautiful scenes in pursuit of that perfect social media shot. Remember to notice the good stuff at your feet, spend time examining an interesting rock, and appreciate the small details that make each hike unique. Not every moment needs to be photo-worthy to be meaningful.
You might also enjoy…
10. Speed Isn’t Everything
The rise of FKTs (Fastest Known Times) and competitive hiking has placed undue emphasis on pace and distance. There’s nothing wrong with hiking slowly or covering short distances. Some of my most rewarding experiences came from leisurely walks where I stopped frequently to observe, reflect, or simply enjoy being outdoors. I always say: “If you got off the trail faster than I did, that just means I spent more time in nature than you.” Who’s winning, here?
11. Is Death Central to Hiking?
Here’s my most controversial take: the only real difference between a walk and a hike is the non-zero chance of death. Dramatic? Perhaps. But it highlights an essential truth: hiking inherently involves risk and self-reliance, and that is precisely what makes it so rewarding.
If there was no chance of dying, was it really even a hike?
Finding Your Own Path
Maybe you disagree with these takes, but I hope this list inspires you to examine your own hiking philosophy more deeply. The beauty of hiking lies in discovering for yourself what works best for you.
What controversial hiking opinions do you hold? Share them in the comments below…
Read More
Get full access…
Get instant access to the full version of this site and enjoy great supporter benefits: full galleries, full trail notes, early access to the latest content, and more.
Hot on the website right now…
Follow for more…
Follow my @TotalCatskills content on Instagram for regular hiking inspo and safe, inclusive community.