6 Feet Under: How Our Adirondack Hike Turned Deadly Serious

Similar Entries In: Hike Safety, Home Page, Recommended Reads, Technique, , .

Esther Mountain Adirondack trail sign

Can confirm!

Disclosure: This content may contain affiliate links. Read my disclosure policy.

What started as a straightforward hike turned into an “adventure” that taught us valuable lessons about wilderness safety and respecting nature’s boundaries. Here’s our story and what we learned from it.

This was supposed to be a well-trod twofer: Whiteface Mountain in the Adirondacks and then, on the way back down, my hiking partner and I would head out to Esther Mountain, a relatively short spur-like hike off the main drag.

Whiteface Was Fine

The hike up Whiteface was uneventful, until we got near the summit. Then it turned into one of the most intense and dramatic experiences I’ve had anywhere. It was cinematic, stunning, wild. The photographs I took up there are some of the best photos I’ve taken, ever. It was incredible.

After descending Whiteface, we regrouped, decided to attempt Esther and, after a short snack, headed out from the junction. It’s technically classified as a bushwhack, but experienced hikers know there’s usually a strong herd path to follow.

Until, suddenly, in winter conditions, there isn’t.

When Things Went “Oh Fuck” Bad

We reached a point where the herd path abruptly ended. Someone had placed a log across the area where we might have continued—a universal wayfinding signal in hiking that clearly means “not this way.” Instead of turning back, we scanned the area and followed what appeared to be solid footing.

Bad move.

About a minute after stepping off the established herd path, the situation deteriorated rapidly. Like bad-bad. Like, “oh fuck” bad.

Whiteface
Conditions on Whiteface Mountain, earlier in the hike

Initially, I thought we were walking on maybe four or five feet of snow. Wrong. I plunged into what winter hikers call a “spruce trap”—a deep pocket of snow around a tree’s lower trunk that forms a dangerous hidden cavity. The trap I fell into was at least six feet deep.

Luckily, I reacted quickly, and managed to pull myself out in about a minute. But my hiking partner wasn’t as fortunate. Her snowshoe became entangled with a branch deep in her trap, and she couldn’t budge at all. She struggled and struggled and couldn’t move even a little.

Getting into the trap to help her out could make things worse, so we focused on staying calm and working methodically to try different solutions.

We spent a stressful 20 minutes trying to free her. Did I mention the Arctic conditions? Temps in the Fahrenheit teens (-12°C) with 35 mph winds. Not great. Finally, somehow, she managed to wiggle her foot out of its boot and climb out of the hole.

This solved the main problem—but created another. Now her boot and snowshoe were stuck down in the trap, buried under feet of snow.

Not a good situation when you’re in deep winter backcountry.

The Rescue Operation

I reluctantly hopped back into the hole (something you never want to do voluntarily) and spent maybe 15 minutes digging to retrieve her snowshoe. The confined space made it challenging. Every time I moved some snow, more snow would tumble in. As I worked, I felt a second hole open up under my left snowshoe. I looked down into pitch black. Big yikes.

But we couldn’t leave essential gear behind. We were still several miles from the trailhead, and steep ones.

My oversized clumsy mittens came to the rescue. Using them like flippers, I was able to move a lot of snow from where the snowshoe was and dump it into the second trap. This is surprisingly tiring work. It’s light fluffy snow but, as you move it, fresh powder immediately replaces what you’ve just moved. It feels endless. Finally, though, I was able to pull out the buried snowshoe.

After getting everything back, we started moving again.

Immediately, I fell into a second spruce trap.

I managed to extract myself, but climbing out of a trap is draining, especially when you’re already tired. This second effort took a toll.

You might also enjoy…

Lost in the White

We tried to retrace our steps to find solid ground, but 40 minutes had passed and the wind had largely drifted snow over our earlier tracks. Winter conditions in the Adirondacks can change rapidly, and our path was disappearing before our eyes.

Then I fell into spruce trap number three. Yep. Third one. According to my partner who was hiking behind me, I just went straight down, vanishing into the pit. By this point, I was genuinely concerned. The physical exertion of repeatedly escaping these traps is substantial, and each one carried the risk of injury or worse.

Conditions
Conditions were like this

Again, I managed to free myself and, very fortunately, that was the end of the drama. We reconnected with the main trail and made our way off the mountain without further incident.

The Deceptive Wilderness

This was all very humbling. What we had mistaken for small fir saplings were actually the tops of adolescent trees poking through the deep snowpack. There must have been 8-12 feet of powder snow in that area.

This realization put our experience into perspective. We hadn’t just stepped off a trail—we had been walking across the canopy of a buried forest, with dangerous voids lurking beneath every step.

What We SHOULD Have Done

Looking back, we made several errors. If you’re planning winter hikes in the Adirondacks (or anywhere with similar conditions), here’s what we learned:

  1. Never bushwhack in the Adirondacks during winter. Just don’t. The established trails are challenging enough, but the herd paths can be treacherous. The amount of snow accumulation creates dangerous conditions that aren’t immediately apparent, and standard navigational markers may be obscured.
  2. If you ever step off a trail or herd path, immediately retrace your steps. The moment you realize you’re no longer on solid ground or an established path, turn around and go back to the last place you felt safe. Don’t try to forge ahead or find an alternative route. Return to known territory first, then reassess.
  3. Respect trail markers and signals. That log across the path wasn’t placed there randomly. Other hikers were trying to communicate something important. When you see these signals, heed them.
  4. Understand the terrain beneath the snow. What looks like a flat field of snow could be concealing dramatically different terrain underneath. Those “small trees” might be the tops of much larger ones, with dangerous voids around their trunks.
  5. Always hike with a partner in winter conditions. Had either of us been alone, this story might have had a very different ending. Having someone to help in an emergency proved invaluable. We got this part right, phew!

Check Yourself

Our experience serves as a reminder that even experienced hikers can find themselves in dangerous situations when they underestimate winter conditions or deviate from established paths. The Adirondacks in winter are stunningly beautiful but demand respect and caution.

Next time, we’ll stick to the marked trails and save the bushwhacking adventures for summer months when the risks are more manageable.

Read More

Get full access…

Get instant access to the full version of this site and enjoy great supporter benefits: full galleries, full trail notes, early access to the latest content, and more.

Hot on the website right now…

Follow for more…

Follow my @TotalCatskills content on Instagram for regular hiking inspo and safe, inclusive community.

I also stay active on Facebook and Threads.

Your comments are welcome here…